Quantcast

Mercy Or Murder? - LEX18.com | Continuous News and StormTracker Weather

Mercy Or Murder?

Posted: Updated:

LAUREL COUNTY, Ky. (LEX 18) - A Laurel County man shoots his wife in the face and surprisingly to some, calls 911 himself.

Ernest Chumbley's wife was suffering terribly from cancer, and he said she wanted to die.

To avoid murder conviction and possible life sentence, Chumbley plead guilty to manslaughter.

Now, behind prison walls, he's locked away for 15 years for what he calls "love."

When asked if he did the right thing, he said yes. He takes full responsibility.

Responsibility for ending his wife's pain, which is what he said she asked him to do.

However, police have a different story. They said he was weary or angry of his wife's medical problems, and shot her three times on August 28th.

"I don't think it's a crime really," he said.

Ginny Mae, his wife, had battled cancer since 2006.

"It come back and it come back, as they say, on a vengeance. Brain, lung and bone," Chumbley said.

He remembers the night he killed his wife.

"Talking and watching Netflix, and we got to talking about her pain. She asked me to do something," he said. "That's what I did."

The Chumbleys' story spread to other states, even a few other countries. To some proponents of the "right to die" -- when a terminal patient chooses when to stop living -- Chris is a victim himself.

"As far as doing something that my wife asked me to do," he said. "Through good and bad, sickness or health, and that's the way I look at it now. I held my vow."

Later, Chumbley's case was compared to William Dresser's in 2014. Dresser shot his wife in the chest after a fall left her a quadriplegic. The prosecutor decided not to try him for murder and dismissed all charges.  Dresser and other witnesses said his wife had asked several people to help her die.  

But other than Chris, no one ever came forward saying Ginny Mae wanted to die, or asked anyone to end her pain. 

Chris said he did the right thing, and he'll see her again when his own time comes.

"She'll come to me with open arms."

During the court case, Ginny's family didn't believe Chris and wanted him to feel the full consequences under the law.

The right to die, or mercy killing, is one of the most hotly debated issues in our country.

WEATHER
MaxTrack Doppler
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Scott County Amber Alert Canceled, Child Found Safe

    Amber Alert Issued In Scott County

    Saturday, August 19 2017 12:34 AM EDT2017-08-19 04:34:03 GMT

    SCOTT COUNTY, Ky. (LEX 18) - An amber alert has been issued out of Scott County after a 4 year old was taken from a home Friday afternoon.  The Sheriff's office says around 6:30 p.m. Friday, they responded to a home on Mcintosh Drive for reports of a break in.  They say when they arrived they found Kayla Samantha Melton, 25, had broken into a home through a back window.  We're told she then assaulted a female who was watching Tayden Bradley Kanatzer, 4, and took him ...

    SCOTT COUNTY, Ky. (LEX 18) - An amber alert has been issued out of Scott County after a 4 year old was taken from a home Friday afternoon.  The Sheriff's office says around 6:30 p.m. Friday, they responded to a home on Mcintosh Drive for reports of a break in.  They say when they arrived they found Kayla Samantha Melton, 25, had broken into a home through a back window.  We're told she then assaulted a female who was watching Tayden Bradley Kanatzer, 4, and took him ...

  • ATV Crash Results In One Fatality

    ATV Crash Results In One Fatality

    Saturday, August 19 2017 8:28 AM EDT2017-08-19 12:28:08 GMT
    MGNMGN
    MOREHEAD, Ky. (LEX 18) –  A teenager is dead after an ATV crash in Elliott County.  Kentucky State Police say two ATVs crashed on HWY 1620 just before 11:30 Friday night. They say Christopher Arthurs, 18, of Olive Hill, was headed north on the highway when his ATV hit the back of another ATV driven by Tyler Rayburn, 19, of Olive Hill.  Arthurs was thrown from his vehicle and taken to a nearby hospital where he was pronounced dead.
    MOREHEAD, Ky. (LEX 18) –  A teenager is dead after an ATV crash in Elliott County.  Kentucky State Police say two ATVs crashed on HWY 1620 just before 11:30 Friday night. They say Christopher Arthurs, 18, of Olive Hill, was headed north on the highway when his ATV hit the back of another ATV driven by Tyler Rayburn, 19, of Olive Hill.  Arthurs was thrown from his vehicle and taken to a nearby hospital where he was pronounced dead.
  • Employee At Home For Abused Girls Accused Of Sexually Abusing One Of Them

    Employee At Home For Abused Girls Accused Of Sexually Abusing One Of Them

    Friday, August 18 2017 6:06 PM EDT2017-08-18 22:06:17 GMT

    ROWAN COUNTY, Ky (LEX 18) The Sunrise Children's Center in Morehead is a home for neglected or abused teenage girls. One of their employees responsible for caring for these girls is now accused of sexually abusing one of them. The center houses girls from 7th-12th grade. The facility only has 12 girls living at the home at a time. "We have residential programs where teenage youth come and live and receive therapy and food and clothing, and a safe place to lay their head down at...

    ROWAN COUNTY, Ky (LEX 18) The Sunrise Children's Center in Morehead is a home for neglected or abused teenage girls. One of their employees responsible for caring for these girls is now accused of sexually abusing one of them. The center houses girls from 7th-12th grade. The facility only has 12 girls living at the home at a time. "We have residential programs where teenage youth come and live and receive therapy and food and clothing, and a safe place to lay their head down at...

Powered by Frankly

© LEX18.com 2017, LEX18.com
A CORDILLERA COMMUNICATIONS Station
All rights reserved
Privacy Policy, | Terms of Service, and Ad Choices

Can't find something?