NewsCovering the Nation


Boeing employee raised concern about design of Max system

Dennis Muilenburg
Posted at 6:42 PM, Oct 30, 2019

Two days of congressional hearings have produced internal Boeing documents showing that company employees raised concerns about the design of a key flight-control system and the hectic pace of airplane production long before two 737 Max jets crashed.

Angry lawmakers bombarded the hearings' star witness, Boeing CEO Dennis Muilenburg, with questions and lectures. They asked why he got a pay raise last year and whether anyone is being held accountable for the crashes, which killed 346 people.

One of the revelations concerned Boeing's design of an automated flight-control system that played a part in both accidents, pushing the planes' noses down until each plummeted to Earth.

The House Transportation Committee on Wednesday released a redacted copy of a 2015 email in which a Boeing expert questioned making the flight system called MCAS depend on just one sensor to measure the plane's pitch — its "angle of attack," or AOA.

"Are we vulnerable to single AOA sensor failures with the MCAS implementation or is there some checking that occurs?" the employee wrote.

Boeing went ahead with the single-sensor design, with no backup to prevent MCAS from pushing the plane into a dive. Investigators believe faulty readings from a single sensor triggered nose-down commands before both crashes.

At Wednesday's hearing, and one the previous day before the Senate Commerce Committee, lawmakers angrily blasted Boeing's CEO over the design and marketing of the Max. Several said the company had put profits above safety.

Rep. Peter DeFazio, D-Ore., chairman of the House panel, said Boeing showed a "lack of candor all through this." DeFazio and others highlighted Boeing's failure to tell pilots about MCAS until after a Max crashed a year ago in Indonesia.

They hammered Muilenburg over his compensation, which rose last year to $23.4 million, including more than $13 million in extra incentive pay, according to a regulatory filing. Some called for Muilenburg to step down as CEO. The Boeing board stripped him off the title of chairman this month.

Muilenburg explained changes Boeing is making to the Max and other steps it is taking to improve safety. He conceded that the company "made some mistakes" in designing MCAS and telling regulators and pilots about the system.

"We are learning, we still have more to learn, we have to work to do to restore the public's trust," Muilenburg said.

Some members of the panel defended Boeing and the Federal Aviation Administration, which certified the plane.

The committee's top Republican, Sam Graves of Missouri, said he wasn't absolving Boeing of mistakes but put some of the blame on foreign pilots. A preliminary report on the second Max crash, in March, revealed that the Ethiopian Airlines pilots were flying so fast it might have hindered their ability to overcome an MCAS malfunction.

"I guess we're going to have to start building airplanes to the lowest common denominator ... if we're going to export" planes, Graves said.

Muilenburg was accompanied at this week's back-to-back hearings by the company's chief engineer, John Hamilton, who fielded most of the technical questions. It was the first time that Boeing officials had testified before Congress about the crashes.



— The Boeing CEO acknowledged that he knew before the second crash that a senior Boeing test pilot had raised concerns after trying MCAS in a flight simulator. That surprised lawyers who are suing Boeing on behalf of families who lost relatives on the flights.

"The CEO knew about this email and text after the Lion Air crash. There is no excuse for not grounding the fleet at that time," said Nomaan Husain, a Houston lawyer,

Rep. Rick Larsen, D-Wash., said he believed the test pilot was complaining about MCAS, but Muilenburg said Boeing's "best understanding" is that he was actually reporting problems with the simulator. The CEO isn't sure because Boeing hasn't been able to interview the pilot, who now works for Southwest Airlines. The Seattle Times has reported that the pilot refused to provide documents to federal investigators, invoking his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.

— A senior Boeing manager complained that workers were being pushed too hard to churn out 52 of the 737s a month in 2018, raising safety issues at the factory near Seattle. In an email obtained by the House committee, he urged a superior to stop production, and said he was hesitant to put his own family on a Boeing plane.

Muilenburg said the manager, who has since retired, "raised some good concerns" that the company has addressed. However, Boeing didn't reduce the production rate until this April, when the grounding of the Max halted deliveries of new Max jets.

— Boeing had money riding on making sure that the FAA didn't require extensive pilot retraining because of MCAS.

Boeing had promised Southwest a rebate of $1 million per plane — $280 million at current orders — if pilots needed extensive training for the Max. DeFazio said this put pressure on employees to make sure the Max didn't trigger a requirement for that additional training.

— Congress is likely to consider changes in how the FAA certifies new planes.

While the hearings focused on Boeing, lawmakers heaped plenty of criticism on the FAA, especially its longstanding practice of deputizing employees of Boeing and other manufacturers to test and analyze the safety of critical aircraft components. At least one bill has already been introduced; other lawmakers pledged to make their own proposals.

— There was no news on when the Max will fly again.

Boeing has been spending months revising MCAS, tying it to an additional sensor at all times and making it less powerful. The company hopes to win approval before year-end from the FAA to get the Max back in the air. Regulators in other parts of the world have indicated they may take longer to review Boeing's changes to the plane.